Showing posts with label Caitlyn O'Leary. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Caitlyn O'Leary. Show all posts

GRR Reviews Her Fierce SEAL: Midnight Delta Book 6 by Caitlyn O'Leary


While the overall plot wasn't bad in "Her Fierce SEAL", the author made the fundamental mistake by making her MMCs US Navy SEALs, as this book had them running around the US being bodyguards, law enforcement, going undercover like spies, and stuff they were NOT supposed to be doing BY LAW (i.e. deploy in the US) that made the book fundamentally flawed.

To recap, Finn Crandall had to deal with the aftermath of his undercover assignment and he regretted not having saved as many of the victims as he could have on all his previous assignments, and it's eating him up inside. He asked for leave and fled to Texas, and happened to run into Angie Donatelli, a PI trying to reunite a mother with her baby who was kidnapped and sold to illegal adoption. Angie always relied on herself, even when taking down monsters who beat up women and paid a price for it too. And when Angie's life was being threatened, Finn's protective instincts kicked into full gear, even as they found that the case Angie was investigating had everything to do with Finn and Team Midnight Delta's previous tangle with the bad guys... even as a new link with the Bratva appeared with a link to a corrupt general, it is time for Midnight Delta team and Angie's family to take a stand...

SEALs are not spies, mercenaries, or bodyguards. Due to this FUNDAMENTAL problem contrary to reality, it is impossible to give this book a higher than average mark. Add to the unrealistic shootout scenario that had the SEAL team members acting as if they're in an Old Western shootout (knock out the glass in the window and shoot back!) and you're left with a "SEAL abuse" novel that the author arbitrarily slapped "SEAL trope" onto a bunch of generic alpha military males.

Strangely, the first novel, where the lieutenant rescued someone while on his midnight jog, wasn't that fact-abusive. But it seems every subsequent novel the fact abuse got worse and worse. There are much better romances dealing with on-duty SEAL or even ex-SEALs that don't abuse reality like this.

Category: Romantic Suspense / Military

Primary Plot: SEAL on vacation ran into private investigator who was working a case he used to be involved in; baby trafficking...

Tropes: disguise, SEAL, private investigator, kidnapping, protector, woman in peril

Overall Rating:  2/5

GRR Review Her Loyal SEAL (Midnight Delta Book 2) by Caitlyn O'Leary

Her Loyal SEAL illustrates how romance authors are just fetishizing the SEALs by portraying them as generic badasses rather than using them realistically. While the story started fine, the remaining of the book puts the SEALs in violation of so many laws and violated the "show, don't tell" basic narrative law so many times that by the time the book ended, the romance is barely recognizable, plus the extra bits to introduce the additional characters for the subsequent novels left the plot points dangling just a bit too much, resulting in a BAD book.

WARNING: The rest of this reviews contains MANY spoilers.

The book started with a bang... SEALs are attacking a compound in the Mexican jungle where the Hidalgo family (mama, papa, and two daughters) are kept, soon to be murdered as an example of what happens to traitors to the cartel. Lydia, the older daughter, was severely beaten. And there was the first problem... They had to walk several DAYS to reach their extraction point, really? And they had brought enough food to feed the family as well? Mexico is not *that* big!

From here on, reality slipped further and further away. Despite efforts by US Marshalls to admit Lydia under assumed name to the hospital to treat her injury, Clint Archer, the SEAL that carried her out, literally on his back, was able to locate her and the Marshalls actually admitted him to see her! This was handwaved away as "I'm a hacker".

Then the family was split up, with mama and papa in one location, little sister Beth in another, and Lydia protected by Clint (why split them?) Then a phone call compromised two locations and Lydia had to call in help from her "hacker friends" which introduced yet another girl, "Riley Jones" to be main character in a later novel. Riley dropped off some info and disappeared a few pages later. Beth gets her novel later as well.

Also, while Clint may be on leave, one call and SEALs ended up taking over protection duty FROM the Marshalls (who has traitors in their midst). This violates the navy regulations so hard (it has the same effect as the posse comitatus act that prohibits Federal Troops from being used in the US homeland with limited exceptions) this can only be described as "utter fantasy".

Later the SEAL team was called off to conduct the assault on the Cartel Kingpin's compound (isn't that MEXICAN military's job?), and somehow the team members in the US can track them as if watching Call of Duty replays without going through headquarters or seeking permission.

The entire book is full of far-fetched unrealistic portrayal of various items, situations, and people that cannot POSSIBLY be true, but merely made everything "convenient" for the plot to continue. While literary license is sometimes called for, this is beyond the pale. Add to which situations merely described rather than shown (violating the "show, not tell" edict, over and over again), this book is, I hate to say this, deserve to be sunk in the Marianas trench.

Again, I emphasize: SEALs are NOT generic heroes. They are NOT bodyguards, babysitters, police, or search and rescue, They are elite navy commandos you send in when you want recon or destruction. Sending them to guard witnesses, rescue hostages, babysit pretty girls, or conduct police raids  are not only wasting their training, they can be downright ILLEGAL!

Category: Romantic suspense

Primary Plot:  SEAL falls for the girl he rescued from the jungle of Mexico, need to protect her

Tropes: SEAL, search and rescue, protector , woman in peril

Overall Rating:  1/5 (I'd put in 0 if I could)

GRR Review: Her Vigilant SEAL by Caitlyn O'Leary

Her Vigilant SEAL by Caitlyn O'Leary was a "strong protector" trope novel that featured relatively shallow characters but decent romance.

Sophia Anderson takes care of everybody except himself. When her mom got sick and her dad ran off, she's overwhelmed with school AND caring for her sick mom, that her little brother was placed in foster care. When her little brother ran away to find their dad, she had to venture into the darkest corner of LA... Mason Gault was a SEAL on leave with insomnia and was out walking when he came upon Sophia being attacked and his protective warrior spirit kicked in and rescued her, but Sophia will not let anyone help her, since she knew she cannot rely on anybody's help, even as she understood that Mason does not want anything in return. When the thugs that attacked Sophia wanted revenge, Mason must summon his team for a rescue mission.

What basically happened is Sophia was doing hard-to-get (but not intentionally) while Mason, the SEAL team leader (the LT) was trying his best to melt the walls around her heart and not wanting anything in return, with the patience of a saint. The ending was basically SEALs going vigilante, which is... kinda heroic I guess.  Honestly, I don't get a sense that these are SEALs at all. They could be any military or ex-military guys.


Category: Military / Contemporary

Primary Plot: SEAL on leave have to rescue a woman looking for her younger brother in the bad parts of LA

Overall Rating: 2.5/5 rounded up to 3/5

Latest Update

GRR Reviews He Said Together by Ruth Cardello